Monday, August 4, 2014

August 4

Evening

It looks like the war has run out of gas. Mothers are starting to talk about seeing their kids again. Jewish grandmothers already started cooking. Just in case!

Unless Hamas gets a Lucky Strike again. Bigger than random shots in Jerusalem on Mount Scopus which gravely hurt a soldier waiting for a bus. Bigger than killing a civilian by driving a tractor into a bus. If that seems loony to you, please know it seems pretty crazy to people here too. It is lunatic. Yet it is not the first time an Arab ‘borrowed’ a machine from a construction site and turned it into an instrument of destruction. Last time it was a borrowed bulldozer. Bet you didn’t know that!

Lucky Strikes need oxygen to light and this war is running out of oxygen. Such intensity just can’t last forever. Fires eventually burn out just as a third of missiles were fired (3,000!), while a third were destroyed, and probably a third remain. Hopefully no more tunnels go cross-border (32), though apparently hundreds of other tunnels remain. Israel did not raze Gaza by any means. But they did create damage, with the goal of creating deterrence. Hamas has, as Netanyahu warned, paid a price.

It is hard to imagine that it will bring about a lasting peace, but more about that next blog. This one is to just give a shout out to the soldiers. We hope you are all home this weekend! Not just sitting on Gaza’s border! Sleeping in your own bed. Eating the cakes already being baked. As many kinds of food as there are soldiers in the army: French, Arab (100% of Israelis who are Druze, a Muslim Arab sect in Lebanon-Syria-Israel corridor, serve– bet you didn’t know that!), Bedouin (many volunteer), Eastern European, Ethiopian, Sephardic/Mizrahi, South American, South African. Forgive me please if I left you off the list, it is not nearly complete.

I am fervently hoping our Shabbat table has one extra family member. Chances are good, but certainty does not sit easily in the Middle East. Must be the sandy foundation, so great for digging you-know-what.

All over this country families will be grieving, doing aftermath analysis and celebrating their soldiers, especially Eitan, Eric’s former commander, who defied protocol and leapt into a dark tunnel after his soldier, like a father into shark-infested waters after his child. Eitan took off hundreds of meters  into that hostile tunnel in pursuit of armed terrorists, and though there was no soldier retrieval to be made, he collected valuable intel. And amazed his troops and his country. Last May Eitan handed Eric a Purple Beret and an award for excellence, and now all of Israel is giving Eitan the equivalent of a Purple Heart for Bravery, very special, very rare.  

http://www.jewishpress.com/news/breaking-news/meet-a-hero/2014/08/04/

And Eric is hopefully going to be present at our dinner this weekend. The dancing and the candy the Gazans and West Bankers distribute to celebrate the ‘victories’ of killing civilians and soldiers alike will stay on the other side of the wall. In Israel, wars, necessary for survival, always end in pain and reflection.

But you still gotta eat.


Greetings from two Americans with one foot out of Gaza

August 4

Tel Aviv suburbs

Day 19 of the war

Most troops are now stationed outside of Gaza, in nearby Israel. Eric is 2km inside Israel, and called us on a day of half-washing and half-resting. He is still borrowing phones; hasn't had his own iPhone in his hand since July 17th - a 20-something with no phone itself seems monumental - because they're still conducting spot raids on tunnels and 'other targets.'

Meanwhile further back in the interior, at 5pm last night Jacques and I took a neighborhood quiz. If your remote to open the parking gate stops working, you:
a) enjoy a lovely late afternoon walk in your suburban neighborhood
b) have the nice guy in the neighborhood hardware store replace the battery for you for ten shekels
c) photograph the Iron Dome intercepting a missile overhead as you get back home, while your wife crouches near the only building available
d) all of the above



Is it a bird? Is it a cloud? No, it's moving; it's a bomb. It is a long time, a minute and a half, to crouch and wonder what would happen if that bomb you can see in the sky actually hit. Where Eric is, he has a tenth that long to take cover. Some people have nerves of steel. I try to imagine the brave guy who dove into a tunnel after the suicide bomber popped out. What he found inside was grim, and indeed we lost three. Rafiah also lost lives, and tunnels and buildings. Spot raids continue. Seven more soldiers were injured yesterday in Gaza.

And... we are starting to think about the end of the war. Whatever that means. More about that tomorrow.

Sunday, August 3, 2014

August 2-3

Saturday/Sunday (Weekend edition)

Tel Aviv

Days 17 and 18 of the war

One of the rewards of Shabbat dinner is the attendance of young adults, the kids of my husband’s childhood friends and my daughter’s Garin sisters in arms. It’s Israel; families stay together on weekends, even after each has a driver’s license.  As a frequent visitor and now a mom of two soldiers in wartime, I feel embraced by the new generation. The girls in particular call to check up, bake a cake (chocolate, my ultimate comfort) and share sophisticated world views that I could not have formed at their age. In truth, I cannot keep up with them and it occurs to me that maybe banners thanking soldiers are right, and I have to cede. Maybe I do stand on their shoulders. Maybe it is already their time.

Hanging out with young adults means going to bed late, so I was completely jarred by Hamas’s siren at
6am on Saturday morning. Iron Dome… I know. But we still got up. I got to sleep at 2am. So 6am was only four hours later. Really Hamas? The early siren in my ear put me in a dark mood for a while, as I contemplated men (surely not women!) who would give the order to shoot a rocket at Tel Aviv. Rather barbaric, to borrow White House spokesman Josh Earnest’s phrase to describe Hamas when they were at that point violating a ceasefire by sending a suicide bomber through a tunnel to blow up and take IDF soldiers with him; 64 fallen. How can leaders encourage humans to die for a cause, while they hide? The family of the soldier the violators grabbed last heard of young Hadar being dragged into a tunnel, though he like another two did not survive this attack. How will they ever step into a tunnel now, without a pang? How will I? It propels me back to when three-year-old Eric, now in battle gear, disliked driving through long, dark tunnels in Switzerland where we lived. We counted the seconds out loud with him until he saw the light at the end. This innocent memory takes on a sinister hue. I need to be pulled back from the brink.

By humor:

By family: Alone I am a pillar, with Sara I am a column, and with Jacques I form a wall, which Eric defends. Jacques is too reserved to blog, though he has a deep reserve of wisdom; he just hasn’t committed to the pour. Instead, in the background he feeds me news and shares two articles by Americans who write from this ‘space’ and time, and make me feel less isolated and less bizarre. Judith Levy (no relation to Jacques), a New York mom at home in Israel, writes from an anguished heart that the world sees Israel as the bad guy. Michael Oren, American-born Israeli historian, author, and former Israeli Ambassador to the United States, writes from a sturdy head that helps us look forward. From each I gained strength.

Judith Levy lamented in “A View From Here” (Israel) 2 days ago, http://ricochet.com/view/ in a way that makes me feel I am looking in a more polished mirror, except I look older, based on the age of her kids. Every example this other Ms. Levy offers up of people hating on Israel “(Mark Ruffalo, Mia Farrow, Penelope Cruz, Javier Bardem, Elvis Costello, Roger Waters, Jon Stewart, Rihanna, Whoopi Goldberg, Ryan Gosling, Eddie Vedder, John Cusack, the list goes on)” is sadly true, but I am as I said the older Ms. Levy, and I know loud stage whispers of opposition always slip out of mouths of uninformed actors in times of war. Remember Hanoi Jane (Fonda)? She repented.  As someone more enlightened lifted Penelope off her Cross (fittingly, Cruz in Spanish). And I hope Ms. Levy caught the delectable diatribe of Jon Voigt who took on the whole list of his silly peers, another share from Jacques, and I thank them both:  http://m.hollywoodreporter.com/entry/view/id/405832.

This time around I suggest that positive outside voices, ie third parties not Jewish or Muslim, are actually louder than ever, though hardly forceful enough, as you still have to strain to catch them. Perhaps not because they are fewer in number – who knows? – but only because they are the more normal, better adapted to society, more enlightened, and less prone to rant. They have, as we say, a life, a meaningful, balanced life. As do, in general, people in Israel. My strongest encouragement for optimism comes from inside this small, cutting edge country, which becomes more attractive and livable every year. The re-born Jewish homeland has lengthening modern roots and deepening modern culture. The British talked of building in Uganda, but our ties are here. This is Judaism’s past, and its present.  Israel is successful, and astonishingly so. Michael Oren yesterday published “In Defense of Zionism.” Jews need and have someplace to come to, and many come just because they want to be here.  Here, in particular. http://online.wsj.com/articles/in-defense-of-zionism-1406918952

There are hundreds of kids like mine who willingly come before, during or after college in America, Canada, Europe or elsewhere to serve, in spite of ever-potential danger. The soldiers right now are caught a war, and we expect they can make Israel safe again so citizens here can stop listening after every loud motor, every sharp pitch, to make sure it isn’t a bomb siren. Soon Israelis will let go of this mild form of shell shock, and get on their lives. But not yet. Yesterday a man in southern Israel was badly hurt when he couldn’t get to a safe room quickly. Shrapnel head to toe. The country remains patiently resolute, and deeply saddened by the loss of life. Netanyahu has the population’s support, and in turn asks for that of every civilized population in the world on television, in Hebrew and in English, while gently suggesting that as Israel goes today, so do they all tomorrow. Islamic terrorism is more anti-West than anti-Semite.

In our way we all defend, by serving, talking, reading, donating, and patronizing businesses that are enduring a long war. We wandered outside for long hours on Shabbat, and many families were out with us. We had a hard time parking. It was heartening. I will never complain about parking again. (Just remind me.) The beach was teeming.  Matkot not rocketot. The port boardwalk boomed with sounds of children, as mothers have 3 kids on average. A brand new baby was being soothed by her young mother and for a moment all was right in the world.

Toddlers played in a sprinkler system right worthy of Epcot Center. Bigger kids zoomed along and we had to sidestep every stripe of scooter, with every kind of driver. Some may be destined to fly planes in the Israeli Air Force, but they will be taught to use big weapons to shed the least blood, ours and theirs.  Warn before a bomb. Aim.  Then leave so you can announce, as today, two tunnel-rid Gazan towns are clear to reinhabit, the only danger now being the booby-traps inside some homes, gifts of Hamas.

On the way home, we strolled past the hall overlooking the beach where Sara attended a Garin sister’s younger brother’s bar mitzvah. If all goes according to Hoyle, in five years that boy will be a soldier, because an army stage of life is surely in store for his generation again. Even though he knows it is coming, the enormity of it will still hit him abruptly but it will also unite him with his peers, and teach him of Israel’s purpose, of its character, and of its characters. Like his older brother, he may choose to still be in the IDF on the day of his wedding. He might then become a father, a grandfather. Who knows how the Arab neighbors will act toward his kids or grandkids, but if Israel remains the same as now, dayenu.

Friday, August 1, 2014

After midnight, August 2

Friday/Saturday

Day 17 of the war

The soldier chain jumped the gun and in fact, the IDF spent all day searching, with no final news of the welfare of kidnapped Hadar, a British Israeli soldier who was taken during a ceasefire at 9:30am yesterday, in southern Gaza. It has been over half a day. The IDF told local residents to stay inside their houses as they search everywhere. The IDF is shelling, which hopefully makes it impossible for the kidnappers to move from that area.

Instead of making me feel better, blogging about a kidnapping has made me sick. War makes you ill. And so terror aims to strike fear and horror into civilian families. For this, Hamas has trained for years, as you can see for yourselves in this video. Welcome to Hamas’ Gaza. Warning: watch on an empty stomach; it will give you a chilling case of war-sickness.
To complete the bilious picture, watch Hamas use television to train its future wives of Hamas. They flat out discuss Jews, not Zionists.  This is threadbare, institutionalized racism. Violent. Hateful.

Obama showed up on Israeli news after dinner, saying all the right things but looking worn down. This war may be getting to him too; Hamas is a dirty player, Geneva Convention rules don’t apply.
On an almost bright note, we heard from our son, who, dirty but fine, dashed our hopes of seeing him for his birthday next week. He said Operation Protective Edge has more to go, and could take weeks. I grieve for the families that have suffered loss, and fear there is more to come. And I miss my son. But he is busy doing good work. Here is a video the IDF released as an example of tunnel busting.The Times of Israel is a great way to keep in touch with Israel, by the way.

http://www.timesofisrael.com/watch-idf-soldiers-uncover-tunnel-shaft-in-mosque/

Jews have always had to fight anti-Semitism, sometimes against the foulest of enemies, and now we have Israel, the only country that can be about and for Jews.On a Friday night like tonight, you can connect with your Judaism, preserved and nurtured, thriving.

I hope Saturday reveals good tidings from the tough neighborhood in which Operation Protective Edge operates. Like Mr. Obama, I look like I could use some good news!
Take sides for peace. 

Egypt and Saudi Arabia demand release of soldier. Last time we got here the US released the pressure on Hamas by opening talks to Qatar (who houses Hamas' Mashaal and the $12 million in aid he said  went 'missing in the war' 2 years ago), and Turkey (who today sent a humanitarian package by sea via Ashdod where, under fire from Hamas rockets, Israelis found boxes of lead ball bearings. Chocolate molds, said Turkey. They put real chocolate and flour in package too. Nice camouflage! The chocolate was the contraband when I sent humanitarian packages to my kids in camp. Why ball bearings? On explosive belts they become deadly shrapnel. Old, established method, tried and true.)

Haven't heard from the US. In America it's still morning. Delegates actually may be in the air, en route to Cairo. 

The kidnapped soldier is dual-British. In Givati, Eric's brigade. 23, Eric's age. These truly are our sons. 

Another Shabbat. 

Jill 

On Aug 1, 2014, at 3:54 PM, Anne Angowitz <anne@preferredplacement.com> wrote:
This Shabbat must include prayers for all the soldiers.  And the one who was just kidnapped.  Have you heard about this in our press yet?  I don’t get the NY Times anymore.  Was it in there?
I had forwarded Jill’s blog page before.  I am going to have to stop sending these around every day so please follow her.   And pass it around.  2lonesoldiersmom@blogspot.com.  

August 1

Friday

Uh oh. As soon as you think you can see the end....

Ceasefire went from cynical to sinister this morning as Hamas took advantage of the 72-hour stoppage to capture a soldier who was performing 'UN permitted' tunnel dismantling. This was a terrible idea, IDF has become a sitting target as it dismantles tunnels in plain view of Hamas.

The parents of the kidnapped soldier have been notified. He is 20, younger than Eric. And there are now 63 soldiers dead, plus more wounded this morning. Some in this war have been wounded so gravely their physical lives are forever altered by this.

This kidnapping will get played out on the international stage, and we all have a front seat to this as talks go on in Egypt, with the US in attendance. First word from the UN is that Hamas committed a foul. Will they keep up that cry? Will others?

A kidnapping puts the peace process in stark relief, and tests the fairness and standards of the players. As it is meant to. If Hamas uses the soldier for a bargaining chip, negotiations are overtly strained. And the longer the IDF stays in, the more chances there are for more such nonsense.

It will be an anxious Shabbat for many. If cool heads and fair hearts prevail, the IDF finishes the tunnels this weekend and gets the hell out of dodge.

[Best article I have read (minus the dodgy rape reference). Written by a Palestinian Canadian. Detente!]
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ali-a-rizvi/picking-a-side-in-israel-palestine_b_5602701.html
Posted by Jill Levy at 4:10 AM
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Anne Angowitz


August 1

Friday

Uh oh. As soon as you think you can see the end....

Ceasefire went from cynical to sinister this morning as Hamas took advantage of the 72-hour stoppage to capture a soldier who was performing 'UN permitted' tunnel dismantling. This was a terrible idea, IDF has become a sitting target as it dismantles tunnels in plain view of Hamas.

The parents of the kidnapped soldier have been notified. 2 soldiers with him have fallen. Obama still asking for return... And there are at least 63 soldiers dead, plus more wounded this morning. Some in this war have been wounded so gravely their physical lives are forever altered by this.

This kidnapping will get played out on the international stage, and we all have a front seat to this as talks go on in Egypt, with the US in attendance. First word from the UN is that Hamas committed a foul. Will they keep up that cry? Will others?

A kidnapping puts the peace process in stark relief, and tests the fairness and standards of the players. As it is meant to. If Hamas uses the soldier for a bargaining chip, negotiations are overtly strained. And the longer the IDF stays in, the more chances there are for more such nonsense.

It will be an anxious Shabbat for many. If cool heads and fair hearts prevail, the IDF finishes the tunnels this weekend and gets the hell out of dodge.

[Best article I have read (minus the dodgy rape reference). Written by a Palestinian Canadian. Detente!]
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ali-a-rizvi/picking-a-side-in-israel-palestine_b_5602701.html
August 1

Tel Aviv

Friday

Day 16 of the war

As we travel around Israel, going about a mostly normal if worried life, we see huge signs strung up on highways, buildings, stores, and restaurants thanking soldiers. No matter the color, with every banner I see red. I am angry. 

I don't want to stand on the shoulders of 18 to 20-somethings. I'm the parent; they should be standing on mine. I'm powerless to stop their deaths, 61 now, and I don't like it. 

Every joke is half truth, and these are addressed to the women here. Life for Tel Aviv women will never be the same now that men know they can leave the house in a minute and a half. (So southern Israeli women who have 15 seconds must be cowboys and sleep with their shoes on.) Donations from moms to soldiers have been disallowed, the soldiers no longer fit in tunnels. Jokes showing basically how powerless we are to stop this. 

Mothers in Gaza are in the same boat. Is this war just to them? Worth the price? Or did Hamas hijack their kids? My Israeli friends reminded me of what I'd read but forgotten. Hamas was elected as a legislative group to work with Fatah. Elected, the party ran - all the way to the Fatah offices in the Gaza Strip and threw Fatah coworkers out, by force. Via the windows. A few stories down. Thus began Hamas rule. Most countries begin with violence. The US did. Israelis are frustrated that their narrative stays so blurry. Because today is clear. They live alongside Arabs. In a free country. With equal rights, it could be a beacon to its neighbors in the region, especially the women.

The prism here is never clear. One Israeli Member of Knesset is a woman and an Arab. Her name is Zoabi. She is anti-Israel. She votes. She speaks her view out loud. In public. When she oversteps and treads on treason, she is temporarily banned from sitting in sessions. She is not fired.  Messy and loud, here is a look at freedom in Israel.

Israel's controversial female, Arab Member of Knesset, Mrs. Zoabi, has a 17-year-old nephew named Mohammed Zoabi. He, his aunt, his whole family are Israelis from near Haifa. This is their home. He's comfortable here. He's got Jewish and Arab friends. He's a normal kid. He's against terrorism, and taped himself on youtube, in 3 languages (my kind of kid) to ask in English/Hebrew/Arabic for the 3 yeshiva students to be released. Immediately! Rather than protect him, Aunt Zoabi denounced her nephew. His own father and grandmother threatened to whisk him off to the West Bank to be harmed. Israeli police intervened. Israeli law protected him. So did his mother, who publicly defended her boy's right to speak his mind. He's only 17, she said! In Gaza he'd be dead. So would his mother. His aunt, a minority woman, would not figure in any government run by Hamas. Life here is rich and full of irony. No wonder women here have iron rich blood. 

Israel is free in the only way a Middle East democracy can be. Messy. There are far-flung orthodox groups here which could be better integrated. Straight lines form with difficulty among people with deep beliefs, and indeed Israelis don't stand in straight lines. They crowd. They push. They don't conform. Yet at every Red Alert siren they immediately, as instructed by homeland security, do the Israeli war version of 'stop, drop and roll' and wait for the all clear before they move on. The younger they are, the more they comply. This death threat penetrates their superman psyche. Three civilians died from rockets. 17 Israeli soldiers died in Israel, most from rockets. Some fired during cease fires. It's been quiet for the first two hours of this new 72-hour one...cancel that... rockets were just fired ... Hamas keeps cease fires like it allows free press. In Gaza reporters are pressured if they write what they see. Lack of free press works for Hamas. It makes Israel looks like Goliath; like it's fighting no one. Although alliances are bending with the times, Israel can feel more like David, surrounded on all sides by terrorists. But there are zero pictures in newspapers of Hamas terrorists. They're not allowed. An Italian journalist tweeted that Gaza hit its own hospital while patients were in it, and destroyed its own Shati refugee camp filled with kids, the first moment he'd passed through Erez Crossing into Israel. Free at last. Most journalists are held in Gaza. Unable to leave. Why did they agree to be there? If they can't report, they distort. We know the UN said Israel hit a second school. Sad. IDF, as with the first school, said it returned fire but details aren't firm yet. We do know now that Hamas bombs killed those kids at the first UN school, just as in the Shati refugee camp. And Gaza hit its own hospital. Hard to avoid if they are, as we know from the IDF, shooting at Israelis near schools, from mosques, and inside its hospital, using the ill as human shields. 

So Israel does need its young men to wear protective gear and march into Gaza to dismantle rocket launchers hidden inside tunnels in civilian buildings. We do need to stand on these soldiers' shoulders. Hamas is weakened. I hate it. 

How did the greatest generation feel about sending their siblings and children off to WW2? Did they think the cause was worth all means? Did our leaders feel justified when they bombed Dresden? Hiroshima? Should Israel not 'pinpoint' as Kerry mocked, and save it's soldiers by dropping full ton bombs from the air? Surely there should be room made for a democracy in this region. Especially one taking in refugees who are fleeing Europe. French Jews streaming to Israel are not coming here for the croissants. If France and Germany still hate, was WW2 well won? Or will that war be, like this one, another in a series of wars fought and refought over the same conflicts?

I pray this war ends at the end of this 72-hour ceasefire, when the terror tunnels will have been plugged. Enough harm to soldiers. Enough violence from Gaza. If Gazan woman could vote, would they keep Hamas?

Inside Israel sporadic riots, near Jerusalem, flame up and are quickly contained. Many Muslim Israelis are tired of conflict. Some Arabs like young Zoabi prefer Israel to Hamas. Christians Arabs in Iraq are given a choice to convert, leave or die, but in Israel Christian Arabs wear a special badge; they are the best educated group in Israel. Something for Jewish mothers to admire! 

Israel's Muslims, Jews and Christians, there is a good reason to follow the path laid clear in North America: Diversity is a strength.